New York State Senate Bill S3596B is currently under review by the state Budget and Revenue Committee—if passed, it would expand the existing state solar energy system equipment credit from 25% of qualified system installation costs with a cap of $5,000, to a cap of $10,000.

The bill also expands upon the language of what qualifies as solar energy system equipment for purposes of the credit – explicitly bringing some battery arrays under the definition. Furthermore, it transforms the credit into a refundable credit for low to moderate income taxpayers or those residing in a disadvantaged community.

Solar Energy Adoption in New York

New York has been among those states at the vanguard of renewable energy adoption. Among other initiatives, New York has required utility companies to provide net metering services—that is, payment to those customers who send more electricity into the grid than they take out.

State governments have historically served as catalysts for the adoption of renewable energy technologies chiefly through such credit regimes, intended to make solar installations more accessible and financially viable for the public. Despite its successes, the program’s limitations have become apparent—with the solar adoption pace in New York City coming in well short of what would be required to meet their ambitious goals.

If it was to garner necessary support, SB3596B could mark a watershed moment in the state’s renewable energy policy—rendering solar installations, already falling in cost per kilowatt, within the budgets of more low to moderate income households.

Challenges and Criticisms

Critics argue the expanded solar tax credit could further strain New York’s already stretched budget—diverting funds from other essential services in pursuit of long term returns on investment. These criticisms highlight the broader political debate around the need to transition to renewable energy while at the same time balancing the costs of administering a state today.

Doubling the existing credit and making it refundable for low to moderate income taxpayers, while retaining a limit of 25% of qualified system installation costs, introduces a nuance to the apparent progressivity of the bill. On the surface, the adjustment appears to enhance the financial incentives for adopting a solar energy system—however, the effectiveness of the credit increase remains tethered to the scale of investment a homeowner is capable of, willing to, or even needs to, make.

In order to leverage the full $10,000 tax credit, a taxpayer must invest in a solar energy system with installation costs amounting to at least $40,000—well above the average cost of a 6kW system in New York, which sits around $13,000. This limitation blunts the effects and limits the field of beneficiaries or those taxpayers that can fully take advantage of the increased cap, shifting the credit more in the direction of moderate- and higher-income taxpayers.

As with many renewable energy initiatives, it is the prerequisite of substantial upfront investment that both hinders adoption and creates a market for predatory practices—like long term exploitative solar leases or high interest rate loans.

Legislative Path Forward

As Senate Bill S3596B makes its way through the New York state legislative process, it will face several more hurdles before reaching an opportunity to become law. Once reviewed by the Budget and Revenue Committee, it must pass the house and senate before being placed on the governor’s desk.

New York currently has Democratic Party control in the governor’s office and both chambers of the state legislature—so the bill has a better than average chance of passage. Nonetheless, the myriad fiscal apprehensions surrounding the state budget could pose substantial obstacles to its enactment. Public opinion plays a crucial role in a piece of legislation’s trajectory, and support from environmental groups, as well as the renewable energy industry, can provide momentum for passage. It remains to be seen if the bill garners that kind of widespread support.

Read the full article here

Subscribe to our newsletter to get the latest updates directly to your inbox

Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.
Multiple Choice
2024 © Budget Busters Hub. All Rights Reserved.